Monday, March 17, 2025

Thursday, December 26, 2024

Sustainable Cider

Folks within my industry keep telling me the cider market is in decline. Really? What timeframe is this based on? 

I can't help comparing this speak with Wall Street's rumors just before the Dot-Com Bubble or the Great Recession. Back then I had an office job, and I was making regular retirement contributions to a mutual fund, so needless to say, all the stock market anxiety was making me nervous too. 

Well, you the history... pop! 

I lost between 40% and 50% of my retirement investments, so it seemed. In retrospect, however, all the money I put those funds (even immediately before those crashes) is ten and five times higher today. So, what does that tell you about making predictions and the good of worrying?   



I had begun planting apple trees in Wurtsboro around that time too, in 2007. I imagined a cider business to supplement my "real work" in architecture, but when the housing market collapsed in 2008, I went all-in the orchard game. Feeling the need to be professional about pomology, I attended an all-day apple conference in Saratoga Springs, NY. I will now relate the only two things I recall of that day: 

 

The first, was a lecture given by a large-scale Hudson Valley apple grower, the kind of generational farmer that's been entrenched in the commodity market since the day he was born. He bemoaned the usual diseases and insects, but his speech was mainly about the financials of a typical apple operation. Factoring the price-per-acre -- including the spray bill, cost-of-sales, and workman’s comp, for example -- he was, in the end, very pessimistic about the sustainability of small-scale orcharding in the 21st century. By his standards, that meant less than 100 acres.

He was, however, a proponent of the “fruit-wall” orchards, claiming the new super-dwarf trees were likely to be the only money-positive option going forward. Even still, he was doubtful American farmers could compete against low-wage or subsidized workers elsewhere. His lecture concluded with this: “If the high-density orchard doesn’t save my farm, I’m not worried. I already have it subdivided on tax maps.”

Cheery. 

 

The other thing I remember that day? I was my first face-to-face encounter with a licensed cider producer. 

About ten years my senior, this guy produced the drink from his family's orchard 3 hours north of me, not far from the seminar, in fact. His bread-and-butter, he told me, was the U-pick operation but he took his cider lineup very seriously. Somehow, in a room full of more than 100 apple growers, the two cider makers found each other like we were both wearing propeller beanies on our heads.

At the time, my cider-producer application was rejected due to my inability to navigate the farm-winery forms (there was no such thing as a "Cidery" license back then.) I knew only two licensed farm-based cider producers, one in Massachusetts and the other New Hampshire (both of whom I wished to emulate stylistically), but since alcohol laws differ from state-to-state, I had no intention of bothering them with my application woes. At the apple conference, I finally had a chance to ask a New York producer how to get started selling "real" cider legally. 

As it turns out, there were as many as six other NY State cider producers I could've called on at the time, but this was the DSL-era and information was relatively scarce. Plus, there was no Cider trade association, nor was the government even familiar with the drink (they thought it was "brewed" like beer and classified it accordingly.) It wasn't until 2010 that an agricultural non-profit advocated for the beverage that there was a network of producers-

Wait, where am I going with this?  

Oh, yeah! I bring this up because I wanted to say: Of the first ten cider producers I met between 2007 and 2011 (all in NY or New England), only one has since gone out of business. And of the next ten I met, between 2012-2014, only two others have quit, albeit for personal reasons and not financial. That's an 85% survival rate, which seems pretty good to me.    


So, there you have it, two competing memories from the apple conference addressing "sustainability" and longevity in the orchard world. And now, if you wanted to know if capital-c, Cider is capable of sustaining your professional aspirations, honestly, I don't know which narrative to heed -- one is a pessimistic outlook, the other is factual --- but I suspect it all comes down to expectations and the timeframe you're imagining.     



How to Sustain a Sustainable Cider Business


I got my license in 2010, so I don't consider myself qualified to talk about longevity, or what is, and what isn’t, a "sustainable cider-business model." That's too short a span. 

Sure, I’ve seen a lot of changes in that time, I’ve seen numerous trends come and go, but 14 or 15 years is a short career in the life of the average person. It's also a short span if you intend to plant "real apple trees", trees from seed, because it might take a decade of more to see fruit. Why, even Bud-9’s will outlive the business if it doesn't survive two decades! So, I won't speak as a veteran of the cider industry (which most people consider me), but I will speak to you as a word enthusiast. Why? Because it's always important to investigate key phrases, such as "sustainability," which has been thrown around willy-nilly in recent years. If nothing else, to be mindful of the meaning of something brings it closer to heart/ closer to integration.  

 

But you already know the definition of sustainable. 

Etymologically, it stems from a combination of “sus” (the precursor of sub, as in below) + “tain” (once meaning, to float) + “able” (suffix meaning, ability.)  In other words, sustainable describes something’s ability to stay afloat (which, again, you already knew.)

But let's NOT overlook that sustainability considers both effectiveness and duration. It's not the same as “whatever works.” Yes, it needs to work, but it also needs to work in the future too. It's about longevity. The trouble is, no one knows the future; And here in lies the first mystery around "sustainable business." 

Anyone can claim adding solar panels or recycling glass bottles is good for the environment (such actions are assumed environmentally sustainable given current information), but it’s a failing of the word to say we know even that with certainty! Acknowledging that we don’t know how things will go is essential to sustainability's definition, but more importantly, it's essential to our attitude if we, in fact, want to behave sustainably.


The other definition of sustainable, if not literal, evokes even more mystery! The way the word is used today suggests a holistic vision, meaning, if we were to create a "sustainable cider business" we'd have to look beyond cider, beyond agriculture, and even beyond business. It’s a holistic consideration (or, substitute whatever nonthreatening word you use) which aspires to bring together the multidimensional aspects of life: the environment, the economy, our culture, and probably a million other things I'm failing to acknowledge.

But to consider “all the aspects of life” is pretty hubris, is it not? I mean, how can anyone claim to be holistic with a straight face? Nonetheless, it's important to think this way (or to try to think this way) if we are to behave sustainably. 

The hope is, if one considers behaving sustainably, it will trickle down and become integrated in our business too. And, hopefully, our business will be sustained.

   

That's a lot of uncertainty. The long and the short of it is, it's impossible to know if Cider will sustain you because it's impossible to know what is sustainable. No one knows the future. Beyond that, I'm unqualified to say anything, but if you’d like to hear me make a fool of myself, this is my advice: 

Ignore everything an MBA grad would say. Embrace uncertainty with a light heart and simply acknowledge that you don't know what will happen. This isn't part of the Wharton/Shark Tank business formula, but you'll be massively advantaged if you have "other reasons" to be a cider maker. Follow that rabbit and do the best you can without worrying about it. 

I'm not saying, "the future is unknowable so don't worry about the financials," but use the information (as much info as you can get your hands on) and don't assume it leads to an outcome. In other words, research things, consider the expertise of others, but attend to your own garden first (or orchard, or cider.) I believe this is the soul of our being, because if we only listened to information no one would ever do anything!  

Embrace that fresh, fun, and liberating attitude in your work, and you'll be far less likely to grow tired. "Resolve always to be a beginner," as Rilke would say. (And if you think this is bad advice, consider Rilke's longevity compared to most people!)   

 

 

P.S. I hope that doesn’t sound pessimistic because ultimately, I have a lot of faith in the way things go. This includes the cider industry. Anyone who knows wild apple trees and their constant ability to surprise, will develop a deep faith in the resourcefulness in all things. If you want to know what the experts say about sustainable apple farming, ask the right ones: the trees. 

Friday, November 22, 2024

Is Cider a Wine?

 



  I recently read an interesting article in Malus Magazine claiming cider is NOT wine, and to think so is detrimental to cider's development. Point taken, sort of. 

  I couldn't agree more about the limitations the "wine" label brings to consumer minds. I especially agree with the author that "cider" liberates producers more than wine does due to the general confusion of where cider is as a category (she used the word "anarchy" to describe this current state), but the author primarily focused on man-made distinctions between cider and wine (words, categories, and market impressions), when, in the end, the two are fundamentally 99% similar. The botanical difference between trees and vines is an interesting one, and worthy of further dissection, but as a drink producer I approach both wine and cider without any real difference. Sure, you can argue the minutia of their differences -- the acids, sugars, esters, etc. -- but there is something far greater that unifies the two drinks: the goal. With both wine and cider, we want to represent the land, we "step back" and let Nature do its thing (rather than taking charge with, for instance: brewing, distilling, or "cheffing" the ingredients.)   

  Even if you want to focus on just the market distinctions (entirely manmade distinctions) and you want to praise cider for i's liberties there; the fact is, a wine maker could be just as free to explore the grape. A wine maker could, for instance, allow for true-terroir* (instead of soil-amended terroir); They could allow for the natural gene expression of grapes; Or they could explore the vine's feral process and "real-world" acclimation. These are issues that some of us are free to explore with cider but no one's stopping a wine maker from doing the same. 

  Plus, wine makers are free to explore co-fermentations (with different fruit) and free to get weird with lab-concoctions too (keaving, "flaw" additions, etc.) as a cider-maker does. Yes, the winemaker would have to forgo the established wine-market lingo (a decision that'd severely limit them economically), but, again, these are only man-made limitations. The only real difference between cider and wine comes down to the nature of the apple versus the grape, which again, share the grander goal of location expression.   

   Ultimately, to label anything is a man-made invention. Words represent our best effort to encapsulate reality for the purpose of communication. They're pods of meaning but they're an artifice, they don't actually embody the reality they're supposedly attached to (don't make me bring up Duchamp or Magritte's Key of Dreams.) Applied to "cider" and "wine", the definitions are literally different but both spark conversations about our place in Nature, our understanding of it, and our ability to MANipulate it to serve our desires. At best, we'll put words to these things and hope the person we're talking to is on the same page, but in the end, no one can definitively understand another's reality. 

  Let's not obsess on linguistics or philosophically, the Western understanding of reality, but let's just agree that we could literally (and I mean literally) interchange "cider" and "wine" if we want to. Neither word exists in Nature, but we're putting them there and appropriately arguing the meaning. Like with any word, its a tug-of-war, and professional marketing is free to MANipulate too. It can be frustrating, but it could also be liberating. I prefer to revel in the freedoms, and if possible, fight for more!  

  So, to sum up my opinion: Both cider and wine have the capacity to explore man-made inventions but more importantly, they could be united by the larger goal of allowing Nature to express itself. I say, follow this rabbit and don't limit oneself by the artifice of capsules or classifications. Lable it "cider" or "wine", I don't care, because to me, they're interchangeable. Just be honest about additions or MANipulations (ask producers to disclose this) but in the end, each of us has the responsibility of direct experience. We create our own meaning of life, which is a good thing, and we should be on guard for when artifice substitutes for it.  

 -------


 BTW, I believe I've done exactly what the Malus author is advocating for. More than most, I've taken great advantage of the liberties of "cider," as a distinct category. This anarchy steered me to "co-ferment" long before it was even a term; It's allowed me to be a "natural" producer ("natural wine" was more fringe back then); and it's allowed me to bottle "pet-nat" before the word was common in the marketplace (actually, I call my ciders "undisgorged" and not "pet-nat" to skirt the attempt to encapsulate real reality within the box of market reality. Plus, I bottle way later than most pet-nat producers.)
The MOST important freedom "cider" has given me, however, was its complete absence of a "terroir" conversation. This allowed me to explore its depths way (WAY) beyond the parameters of viniculture's encapsulated meaning. My mission, if anything, has been to expose how MANipulated farm environments and species are. (*That's why I use my own term, "locational," believing true terroir is incompatible with soil amendments, sprays and irrigation and cloning. I emphasize this by foraging and separating the locations.)

Sunday, November 10, 2024

Apple 101 to 401 (or, How the Basic Properties of Apples Inevitably Leads Us to Advanced Anthropology, Ecology and Philosophical Conjecture)

The first thing to say about apple trees is that they’re not from around here. 

Seeds were first brought over from the “old world” in the early 1600s when European settlers began setting-up shop in the Americas. From the east coast, the apple tree made its way west in the 1800s. Western New York, Michigan, and now, Washington became the U.S.'s largest apple producer. From there, the apple even hopped the vast Pacific Ocean to Japan (Fuji apple), Australia (Granny Smith) and New Zealand (Gala apple) were born from European/American apple lineage. 

But the apple isn’t from Europe either, although genetically, Malus Domestica (the scientific name for the common eating apple) does have some European crabapple in it. The "domesticated apple" is thought to descend predominantly from Malus Sieversii, the baseball-sized apple still growing wild in Central Asia. It was by way of ancient trade routes, such as the Silk Road, that Sieversii genes spread east to west, all way between China to Portugal.  Western Europeans brought it further west, across the Atlantic, and then it even hopped the vast Pacific Ocean to Japan, Australia, and New Zealand, where the likes of the Fuji apple, Granny Smith, and Gala (respectively) were born from European and/or American apple lineage. 

So right off the bat, we are talking about a successful globe trotter, which is important to remember about apples. Malus Domestica has thrived under modern transportation, and it now grows as far north as Alaska and Iceland, as far south as Patagonia and South Africa, and it succeeds anywhere there's cool temperatures for a few nights each year. In fact, apple trees exist in parts of Florida, Thailand and even Bermuda! But the MOST important thing to say about apples is that they're extreme heterozygotes. The reason why Malus has succeeded throughout the planet has to ALL do with this very unique genetic talent. 

Being an extreme heterozygote, the apple tree will never grow true to its seed, just like a human, which has half the number of genes of Malus Domestica. The point of this massive DNA bank is to form new combinations which are designed to test compatibility with different climates and terrains. They also possess an intelligence that allows them to acclimate and adapt to real-time environmental changes. Proof of this is evident in their biennial fruiting pattern. Ferral Malus Domestica, and even MANipulated orchard trees have the ability to read the ecosystem and participate in forest-wide mast years (sometimes known as "bumper crops.") Epigeneticists, the scientists who study adaptive genetics, are only now scratching the surface of Malus Domestica and discovering what the ancients have always know: This is the tree of wisdom.  

"But humans are intelligent too," you say. Well, that may be true but take a closer look at Malus and you'll discover that the genus possesses an intelligence that Homo Sapien do not (not modern, "Western" Man, at least.) For one, they always blend in with environments as they travel the world. They read the pre-existing cultures and know how to co-exist in peace (they participate, not destroy.) We, on the other hand, compete with "what is" and then we out-muscle the other species. We even eradicate other human cultures if they threaten to live in harmony with the landscape! If feeling at peace with the planet is more intelligent than feeling against it, than apples are wiser.  

This is where apple 101 suddenly becomes apple 401, when we reflect on our shortcomings and realize Malus Domestica has succeeded where we have not. Our intelligence, for instance, is in our brain, in our concepts not our being, ruling us to MANdate the environment (dictate how it's "supposed to be".) If you think science is intelligent, guess again. Our MANipulation of the planet has only accellerated and we're constantly re-upping our MANdate to steward the land. We assume we know what's best. 

This vision, this concept, we predominantly realize in the form of agriculture, the 12,000-year-old occupation serving Man's relatively sudden population growth and non-nomadic civilizations. In fact, we call it cultivation, not MANipulation, to suggest actual culturing, but the latter best fits the act of unilaterally altering the environment with only our species in mind. At its worst, agriculture has looked like all-out war with the larger cultures of this planet (the clear-cutting of the Amazon, the American Dust Bowl, and mass extinctions, discarded like mutilated roadkill in our wake, for instance); While at our best, we try to "cultivate" a mutually beneficial ecosystem. 

We know now (or some of us do) that we can't go on bullying the planet with the trajectory of the Western agrarian concept. We are not spiritually or philosophically "other" than this planet, and to continue to uphold that biblical destination is, at this point, clearly suicidal. Instead, some people are reevaluating what cultivation means (a word with deep anthropocentrism in its etymology) and learning of other versions of success/ larger success. Apple trees represent one such version. The tree of wisdom might one day teach us of a more intelligent harmony.   


Saturday, October 7, 2023

"Seeing" Nature


Prologue

Who doesn't love Thoreau? From our vantage point, 150 years more emersed in an industrial landscape than he, the Transcendentalist poet appears more peaceful and grounded by Nature. He was observant and respectful of "the wild," and when we compare his priorities to our own, Thoreau looks like a sage trying to steer Western society in the right direction. 

But from another perspective (and perspective is what this post is all about), Thoreau can appear naive and superficial. When you compare his experience in the American wild to that of the Native American, he comes off as a tourist and his writing seems romanticized. Why should we care about his perspective of Nature when an entire race of people lived closer to the subject and had infinitely more to say about it?  

In the following essay, I want to exploit the gap between these vantage points, and I'm going to quote from Luther Standing Bear, a Lakota chief of the late 19th century. He writes:

We did not think of the American landscape, with its tangled growth, as “wild.”  Only to the White Man was nature a “wilderness”.  To us, the Earth was tame, bountiful, and surrounded with the blessings of The Great Mystery.

----------

Before we go down this road though, we got to make sure you're properly insecure about the subject, Nature (or specifically: Relating to Nature.) Because, if Thoreau was a novice, you sure can't profess to be "in-tune with the wild." We're too disadvantaged now. The whole planet is now affected by Man. 

Plus, our minds are further from wild. We're now born to understand things in relation to thoughts rather than just relating to them directly. Our intellect has become our defense, our distancer from Nature, and the scientific gaze has become our cultural perspective. But this "studying approach" won't gain insight into the Native American perspective and unless we drop this viewpoint (which is all it is), we will only distance ourselves further.   

A wise man once said, "Understanding is the booby prize of life." In other words, there's real observation and participation that could otherwise be had. And if Standing Bear is to be read, we need to accept that we don't (and can't) contextualize Everything. We must accept there's mystery. He uses that word right there his quote, but all Native Americans spoke of Great Spirit and clearly their culture honored mystery. To ignore these words, or to erase them from the study of Nature, would be like studying a tree without acknowledging the ground the tree is attached to (which, BTW, is exactly how specialists are trained to see Everything.)       

So, achieving self-reflection or humility is going to be tall order for us, but it's worth the try. And although I'm in the same boat you are, totally ignorant about my relationship to Nature, I'm going to proceed using the metaphors I studied because that's what I'm familiar with...  

I come from an art background, and I believe that with this subject John Berger might serve us well. . Specifically, I'm going to build off his famous mid-century critique, Ways of Seeing. 

Now, for those who don't know his work, Berger reflects intensely on the art-audience's vantage-point. He points out how art-viewers are not "blank slates", and that they were never given the chance to see art cleanly. He notes how Modern people are born with cultural context that predetermines meaning for us. Our understanding is already formed and it's impossible to erase. For instance, our education and a never-ending bombardment of media-affirmations continue shape our perspective. We can't see without these contextualizations. 

And if we can't see Art for what it is, perhaps we can't see Nature for what it is either. In our minds we already "know" what we're seeing (though, obviously, we don't: History proves we're perpetually taking new information into account, and we have to adjust the "facts" we hold true.) The worst part about our this is, none of us are aware of it! We rationalize our convictions using the same cerebral tools that actually block us from seeing Nature in its' whole!

Well, as for Berger, his critique on art went over the heads of the general audience (his essay effectively changed nothing about the way we see art), but what a shame if this were to happen with Nature! The stakes are high. So, let's begin by looking at the Nature from scratch, without out pre-formed perspective. Let's start by looking at our looking...         


--------------------

Chapter 1.   Deconstructing What It Means "To See"


"To see," is to connect two entities: (1) There's someone doing the seeing, and (2) there's something being seen. 

The eyes are like ambassadors between these entities. They gaze externally, imprinting the world's perceptible properties on to the retina, and then connect internally to the brain via the optic nerve. This is the physical act of seeing that we're all taught, but the dual external/ internal function makes vision a far more profound of a subject.      

If it were just purely physical, seeing would the focus of the ophthalmologists and no one else. But there's another definition that launches deep into meta-physicals (beyond the physical) and this is how we usually use the word. Etymologically, and still in the dictionary, "seeing" is also defined as understanding what we see.  We combine the internal and external.  

Descartes ("I think, therefore I am), for example, thought that the eyes were the crossroads of the soul, like a highway on/off ramp in an ontological relationship between body and mind. Plato, too, emphasized the eye’s role in our relationship to "the Truth" (which, according to the Allegory of the Cave, lay somewhere out there for our discovery.) What we know to be true, according to the Greek, is made possible by where we stand and which direction we're looking. 

You may think these are ancient thoughts but, in actuality, they describe our everyday assumptions. They are still famous because these philosophers laid-down ideas that continue to dominate our notion of the human experience. For instance, when we say, "Do you see what I'm saying?", we're extending Plato's exact metaphor* of The Cave. 

And the reason I'm bringing it up is, the ambiguous relationship between our non-physical thoughts (including personal identity, what we think as "us" verses "other") and our physical senses (like eyesight), is a problem that continues to perplex as we view Nature and ourselves. We still have not discovered a better way of relating to the world other than "internal me" versus "everything outside of me" (although Eastern philosophy and religions offer alternatives.) 


To recap: Perspective influences what we think is real and not. Thoughts change as our vantage-point changes (which seems obvious to say, but for some reason we don't remember it -- or don't believe it -- when only our brain gets involved.) I, personally, believe we need to doubt all understanding (which is just a vantage-point) and keep our eyes open to new discoveries, new positions. And to accept strange statements like that, or anything said by Standing Bear, we will gain access to the bigger picture. 

---   

This is The End, for now. As I said, it's a work in progress and it's part of a book I'm working on. I'll finish it there. maybe

--------------------


*I can't resist reflecting on the word, Metaphor... 

You can see how meta-phor shares a prefix with meta-physics but don't be frightened by that, the definition of metaphysical isn't owned by the religious. Metaphysics is simply the pairing of meta ("behind" or "beyond") and physical. The Greeks coined the word to describe aspects of realities which were in the head and not found in the physical world. Psychology, for instance. Thoughts, feelings, and yes, spirituality are examples of meta-physical study.  

So that's a little on the meta part, but with Meta-phor the suffix is equally interesting. Phor comes from the ancient word bher, which means "to bear", as in a child.  Thus, a Meta-phor is properly defined as something that bears another thing's meaning -- pods to carry another thing forward. Words themselves are examples of metaphor since they bear the definition of a concept we wish to communicate (ipso facto, metaphor is a metaphor of itself!)   

In other words, we don't communicate in physical fact, we communicate in meta-phoric packages. We'd like to think things can be "perfectly clear" between two people but that's an impossible fantasy. Definitions are already subjectified in our heads, but they become further metaphorical as they're communicated and unpackaged by the second person. There is no such thing as understanding between two people, there is only "I, personally, made sense of the information and I think we're more or less on the same page now."   

Monday, March 27, 2023

The Art of Cidermaking: You Already Know It, You Just Don't Know It

[The following is an essay I wrote in conjunction with the discussion-panel of the Holistic Orchard Network website. Go there for further discussion and comments.]

 

Art can not be taught 

You heard right: Art can not be taught. At best, an art teacher can help the student learn how THEY make art, but if the student is not willing to look inside for the way (or if they are fixating on looking for answers) then forget it, Art isn't for them.

Yes, you can teach the formal aspects of art, but you can't teach the artmaking itself because Art is a relationship, not a product. The "product" manifests from the relationship. This is always the case. Art does not, and can not, manifest itself from the formal aspects alone. 

It's important to note: There's nothing elitist about Art because EVERYONE is an Artist! That's right, YOU are an Artist! Do you have a relationship to your family and friends? Then you are an artist -- you have developed a way of relating to them. Do you have a relationship to Earth and the environment? Then you are an artist -- you have developed a way of interacting with the planet. You already have lots of practice with being an artist and in the practice of painting, or the cultivating of apple trees, or cider making, it will all translate into one.  Learn to trust what you already know! 

So, let's be clear: Apple cultivation is a relationship, and so is cider making. RELATIONSHIPS.
If you can remember this then you can approach apple growing and cider making as any artist does (and how all people should.) You will be well positioned to digest the formal qualities as well, which are helpful tools. You will also be able to contextualize what the experts say (the "science of wine making") and know they are full of shit. There are no experts at life, no one lives more than you do, and that's what art is, life. Experience counts for something, just not much. 

---

OK, so you want little-old me to talk about the formal qualities of cider making? Fine, I can do that, as I have on past posts, but DON'T get lost in my knowledge. This is the trap people always fall it and I've seen it a million times. Words are not real, they are just capsels. My ideas can inspire but they can't be learned. Because ART CAN'T BE LEARNED! So this is rule number one: Don't let other people's ideas substitute for YOUR experience of life. You will figure it out. Trust that. You've been doing it all along. 

Rule number 2: Be weary of everyone who is not you! They are practicing their art on you and trying to convince themselves of their perspective. Fine, but don't trust their words. Retaliate with your life because that's the only thing real. Inspect other people's art and take only what is helpful to you.

I might say, for instance, "Dabinett is a good cider apple but it sucks in Northeast soils unless you amend the soils, graft on dwarf, spray and irrigate, etc." (in which case you're removing 90% of the good properties anyways.) 
Or, when I say, "What you really should grow is wild, assimilated trees because it's not the variety, it's how it's grown," keep in mind this is just what I say because it was true with my experience. I have a very different way of relating to the world than you. 
You TELL me how to grow a cider apple! Seriously, that's what Art is:  YOU tell me. 

This means we can all proceed and relax as equals. There are no experts, only more experienced artisans (and that counts for little.) More importantly, as equals, there's no hierarchy of information. It's what matters to YOU. Yes, I've had lots of experience making cider, growing trees, and with Art in general, but my stories and "wisdom" is offered only as a reference. It's your journey.  

Art is relative. It's ALL about relationships. Only you can live your life. So, what's it like?